631-226-1274 | office@saintjohnslindy.com

Onward, Christian Soldiers

by | Nov 5, 2026

With Veterans Day approaching, this pastor recalls one of World War II’s most enduring stories of interfaith heroism: the Four Chaplains. On February 3, 1943, the U.S. Army Transport Dorchester was torpedoed in the icy North Atlantic. Four Army chaplains gave their life jackets to others: George L. Fox, a Methodist minister; Alexander D. Goode, a Jewish rabbi; Clark V. Poling, a Dutch Reformed minister; and John P. Washington, a Roman Catholic priest. They died together, united in service to their shipmates.

Their sacrifice brings me back to a question I wrestled with while studying Christian ethics: How do we reconcile Christ’s call to peace with military service? Scripture includes both accounts of warfare and calls to peacemaking. The Christian tradition’s discussions of just war reflect that struggle. Calling an action “defense” does not, by itself, resolve its moral questions.

These are difficult questions. Yet honoring those who serve need not wait until we have answered them all.

Even our hymns can stir this debate. “Onward, Christian Soldiers,” included in the Lutheran Book of Worship, was omitted from Evangelical Lutheran Worship, published in 2006. Some hear its military imagery as troubling; others hear a call to faithful discipleship.

That tension became personal at my ordination, when my request to use the hymn for the sending procession was declined. It was my late father’s favorite hymn. I had hoped to honor my dad, a proud Marine who served during World War II.

The hymn’s origins offer helpful context. Sabine Baring-Gould wrote it for a children’s Pentecost procession in England during the 1860s. Its cross-led procession and language of spiritual struggle point toward following Christ. I hear an invitation to courage and faithfulness, even as I recognize why others find its imagery difficult.

Military chaplains live with these tensions daily. The ELCA’s Federal Chaplaincy Ministries supports pastors serving in military and other federal settings, as well as seminary students preparing through chaplain candidate programs. Military chaplains provide pastoral care and help safeguard religious freedom for service members of every faith and of no faith. Like the Four Chaplains, they bring compassion into places of fear and danger.

This Sunday, November 8, at our 9:30 AM worship service, we will offer a blessing for all veterans, including military chaplains. We will give thanks for their service, remember its costs, and pray for the peace they and their families long to know.

Blessings,

Pastor Marc